Ask Onix
Centuries-old debate: Can chocolate be healthy?
For hundreds of years, humans have consumed cacao in various forms, but modern chocolate-often loaded with sugar and milk-has sparked a debate about its health effects. While some traditional cultures show remarkable health markers linked to cacao consumption, scientists remain cautious about declaring chocolate a health food.
The Kuna Indians: A case study in cacao and longevity
The Kuna people of Panama's San Blas Islands exhibit unusually low rates of high blood pressure, heart disease, diabetes, and cancer, with many living to advanced ages. Marji McCullough, senior scientific director of epidemiology research at the American Cancer Society, noted their daily intake of four cups of cocoa-cacao mixed with water and minimal sugar-though she emphasized that their diet also includes far more fruit and fish than typical Western diets, alongside an active lifestyle.
"We cannot definitively attribute their health to cocoa alone," McCullough said, pointing to other dietary and lifestyle factors that may contribute.
Flavonoids: The heart-healthy compound in dark chocolate
Research has focused on flavonoids, plant compounds abundant in cacao, which may reduce inflammation and lower blood pressure. A large clinical trial, the Cocoa Supplement and Multivitamin Outcomes Study, found that daily cocoa flavanol supplements (400-500mg) could cut heart disease mortality risk. However, JoAnn Manson, a Harvard Medical School professor and the study's principal investigator, used supplements rather than chocolate to control flavonoid levels, as manufacturing processes drastically reduce flavanol content in commercial products.
Gunter Kuhnle, a nutrition professor at the University of Reading, noted that while the European Food Standards Authority suggests 200mg of cocoa flavonoids (or 10g of dark chocolate) may offer benefits, newer data indicates 500mg daily-roughly one small 30g bar-might be more effective.
The bitter truth: Sugar, fat, and marketability
Dark chocolate's health potential is complicated by its sugar and saturated fat content. Aedin Cassidy of Queen's University Belfast explained that while stearic acid in cocoa butter has a neutral effect on cholesterol, other saturated fats in chocolate may harm cardiovascular health. Additionally, the more flavonoids a chocolate bar contains, the more bitter-and less marketable-it becomes.
"There's a conflict between cocoa's beneficial compounds and what's needed to make it palatable," said Duane Mellor, a dietician at Aston Medical School. He suggested that small portions of dark chocolate could help curb unhealthy cravings, as its bitterness naturally limits consumption.
Bean-to-bar movement: A return to traditional methods?
Smaller chocolate producers are reviving traditional cacao-processing techniques, such as roasting whole beans at lower temperatures for longer periods. Martyn O'Dare, co-founder of Firetree Chocolate, described how Solomon Islands farmers ferment and dry beans before shipping them to the UK, a method that may preserve more flavanols than industrial processes.
"In the early 20th century, companies began roasting only the nibs after mixing high- and low-quality beans," O'Dare said. "This shift may have compromised both flavor and nutritional value."
Expert consensus: Moderation, not miracle cures
While dark chocolate contains beneficial compounds like theobromine-a mild stimulant in the caffeine family-experts warn against viewing it as a health food. Chris Alford, a psychology professor, noted that theobromine provides a "smoother" energy boost than caffeine, but Kuhnle stressed that the sugar and fat in most chocolates likely outweigh any flavonoid benefits.
"Chocolate isn't a health food. Any benefits from flavanols are negligible compared to the risks of overeating," Kuhnle said.
Gunter Kuhnle, University of Reading
Manson recommended obtaining flavanols from other sources like tea, berries, and grapes, while allowing "moderate amounts of high-cacao chocolate" in a balanced diet.
