Ask Onix
Trump administration rolls back tariffs on key food imports amid affordability concerns
The Trump administration last week eliminated tariffs on more than 200 products, including bananas, coffee, and spices-a policy reversal aimed at addressing rising cost-of-living concerns that have weighed on Republican electoral prospects. While industry groups welcomed the move, economists caution its impact on grocery prices may be limited.
Political calculus behind the tariff cuts
The decision follows months of polling data indicating that affordability issues have eroded White House approval ratings and hurt GOP candidates in recent elections. Critics, including business lobbies, had long urged the administration to reconsider its tariff policy, which imposed a baseline 10% tax on imports from all countries, with additional levies on select trading partners.
The Food Industry Association (FMI) called the rollback a "critical step" toward improving affordability, though analysts note the symbolic weight of the move may outweigh its immediate economic relief.
Modest relief for select grocery items
While the order exempts certain staples-such as coffee, tropical fruits, and spices-from tariffs, it leaves intact levies on other food categories, including wine, cheese, and palm oil. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) estimates imports account for less than 20% of total American food and beverage purchases, further tempering expectations of broad price declines.
Anthony Serafino, president of New Jersey-based fruit distributor EXP Group, said his company would lower prices in the coming weeks after months of passing tariff-related costs to consumers. "We're not going to keep prices elevated just to keep prices elevated," he told reporters, though he acknowledged existing inventory might delay visible reductions for shoppers.
Economists temper expectations
Experts warn the tariff cuts will have uneven effects. Yale's Budget Lab projected in October that Trump's tariffs would push food prices up by 1.9% this year-significant given that U.S. grocery inflation averaged just 2% annually between 2013 and 2021. Yet Sean Cash, a food economics professor at Tufts University, said the relief would be concentrated: "You'll see it on certain products, but not a lot in terms of the average grocery bill."
Other cost pressures-such as rising labor expenses, drought-induced supply shortages (e.g., coffee, cattle), and tariffs on packaging materials like aluminum-remain unresolved. Daniel Sumner, an agricultural economist at UC Davis, noted that most food costs stem from services (e.g., trucking, inspections) rather than raw commodities: "Eliminating trade barriers would help a little, but not dramatically."
Broader inflation trends persist
Grocery prices rose 2.7% year-over-year in September, down from peaks of 11.4% in 2022 and 5% in 2023. The administration has blamed high food costs on policies inherited from the Biden era, though officials conceded last week that price reductions are a "goal, not a guarantee."
Sylvain Charlebois, director of Canada's Agri-Food Analytics Lab, compared the dynamic to a receding tide: "The mental mark of high prices lingers. Even if tariffs vanish, industries tend to anchor pricing to that peak." Major retailers, including Walmart, Target, and Kroger, declined to comment on potential price adjustments.
What's next
Economists suggest the tariff cuts could provide targeted relief for specific imports but are unlikely to reverse broader inflationary trends. With labor costs, climate disruptions, and residual trade barriers still in play, the administration's move may prove more politically symbolic than economically transformative.
