Ask Onix
Tragedy exposes cracks in Switzerland's local governance
Switzerland's cherished system of decentralized government faces intense scrutiny after a New Year's Eve fire at a Crans-Montana bar killed 40 people and injured 116, revealing glaring lapses in fire-safety oversight.
The disaster and its aftermath
The blaze at Le Constellation bar, a popular nightspot in the Valais canton resort, erupted shortly before midnight on December 31. Emergency services responded within minutes, but the scale of the tragedy-one of Switzerland's deadliest in decades-sparked immediate outrage when officials admitted the venue had not been inspected since 2019.
Crans-Montana Mayor Nicolas Feraud disclosed that only 40 of the town's 128 bars and restaurants underwent inspections in 2025, blaming a lack of resources. His remarks drew sharp criticism, particularly as Crans-Montana and neighboring Zermatt rank among Switzerland's wealthiest resorts.
"We urgently need complete, transparent answers."
A mother of two survivors, on social media
Questions of accountability and conflict
Journalists pressed Feraud on his relationship with the bar's owners, asking if personal ties influenced oversight. He denied any corruption, but the damage was done. Swiss media lambasted the revelations, with Tagesanzeiger calling it a "failure right across the board" and Blick labeling it an "utter disaster."
Valais President Matthias Reynard vowed a "strict and independent" investigation at a memorial service, warning that "relevant political authorities" would face consequences. Swiss President Guy Parmelin echoed the demand for "justice without delay."
Systemic flaws under the microscope
Switzerland's devolved governance, where part-time local officials manage fire safety alongside schools, taxes, and social services, is now under fire. Critics argue that small communes struggle to meet modern demands, while defenders of the system highlight its tradition of local accountability.
Lawyer Romain Jourdan, representing victims' families, announced plans to sue Crans-Montana's council, demanding all officials be questioned to prevent future tragedies. Calls are growing to centralize fire-safety inspections under cantonal control.
Reputation at stake
Switzerland's global standing-built on safety, stability, and reliability-has been shaken. Past scandals, like the 2001 Swissair bankruptcy and the 2008 UBS bailout, triggered public fury, but this disaster cuts deeper: 40 lives lost, many of them teenagers, and survivors left with lifelong trauma.
At the memorial, emergency responders wept alongside mourners. The contrast between Switzerland's elite emergency services and the failure of basic preventive checks has left citizens questioning the system's priorities.
A nation demands change
As the bar's owner faces criminal charges, the focus shifts to local governance. Swiss voters, who once took pride in their decentralized model, now demand reforms. The tragedy has exposed a painful truth: even the most efficient systems can fail when accountability is diluted by familiarity and resource gaps.
For the families of the victims, justice is the first step. For Switzerland, it may be the beginning of a reckoning.
