Ask Onix
How food expectations influence hunger
The way we perceive what we eat can alter our body's response to food, affecting appetite and weight management more than calorie counts alone, research shows.
The psychology of cravings
Humans are biologically wired to seek energy-dense, sweet foods-a survival trait from early ancestors. However, modern environments overflow with ultra-processed, high-calorie options that often trigger guilt rather than satisfaction.
Ashley Gearhardt, a psychology professor at the University of Michigan, compares ultra-processed foods to a "heavy metal concert" that drowns out the subtler appeal of whole foods. "It's difficult for people to tune into the quiet enjoyment of fruits or vegetables," she explains.
The milkshake experiment
A landmark study by Stanford psychologist Alia Crum demonstrated how expectations shape physiological responses. Participants drank identical 380-calorie milkshakes but were told they were consuming either a 140-calorie "healthy" shake or a 620-calorie "indulgent" one.
Those who believed they drank the indulgent shake experienced a sharper drop in ghrelin, the hunger-stimulating hormone, signaling fullness. The healthy-label group showed minimal ghrelin suppression, despite identical calorie intake. "Believing you've eaten enough makes your body respond as if it has," Crum notes.
Labels and mindset matter
Food labeling influences satisfaction. In another study, participants ate identical protein bars labeled either "tasty" or "healthy." Those who ate the "healthy" bar reported feeling hungrier afterward and consumed more later-even compared to a group that didn't eat the bar at all.
Crum's research also found that people told they had genes making them feel full sooner produced more of the weight-regulating hormone GLP-1, regardless of their actual genetics. This suggests mindset can override biological predispositions.
Rethinking restraint
Strict dietary restraint may backfire. Crum warns that a deprivation mindset can slow metabolism and trigger compensatory overeating. "If you reduce calories but focus on restriction, you might not lose as much weight," she says.
Gearhardt advocates for a pleasure-focused approach: "When we treat food as a chore, it becomes harder to sustain." She recommends emphasizing unprocessed foods-proteins, fruits, and vegetables-while allowing occasional treats without guilt.
A balanced approach
Experts suggest avoiding labels like "light" or "low-calorie," which can create a sense of deprivation. Instead, Crum advises trusting your body's hunger cues. "Eating an indulgent treat mindfully, alongside a balanced diet, can support weight management," she says.
Reducing ultra-processed foods, which lack essential nutrients, may also help curb cravings. As Gearhardt puts it, "Our bodies are designed to find whole foods rewarding."
"Trust yourself to be hungry for the right things at the right time."
Alia Crum, Stanford University psychologist
