Ask Onix
England's Ashes hopes hinge on Brisbane showdown
Twelve days after a crushing defeat in Perth, England's cricket team arrives in Brisbane for the second Ashes Test starting Thursday, with their Bazball philosophy under intense scrutiny. A loss would deepen the series deficit to 2-0, a position from which no visiting side has recovered in Australia since 1954-55.
Pressure mounts on England's approach
The aftermath of Perth saw England subjected to criticism-labeled arrogant for off-field activities like golf outings and aquarium visits, and questioned over their decision to skip a Lions warm-up match in Canberra. Captain Ben Stokes dismissed accusations of arrogance, arguing the team's commitment to Test cricket is evident in players like Jofra Archer and Harry Brook, who have sacrificed personal opportunities to prioritize England.
Yet perceptions persist. Former Australia fast bowler Mitchell Johnson's remarks about England's attitude have fueled debate, while Stokes' insistence that his team "haven't done anything wrong" has done little to quell skepticism. The narrative, Stokes acknowledged, will only shift with a victory.
Historical hurdles and pink-ball challenges
England's record in Australia is dire: 16 winless Tests stretching back nearly 15 years, with their last Gabba victory in 1985. The pink ball under floodlights-a format where Australia's Mitchell Starc thrives-poses another obstacle. With lights activating at 17:30 local time, more than half the match will be played in twilight, demanding adaptability England struggled to show in Perth.
Australia, meanwhile, have not lost three consecutive home Tests since 1988 or three in a row after taking a series lead since 1954-55. Their dominance at the Gabba, where they remained unbeaten from 1988 to 2021, adds to the challenge.
Tactical dilemmas for Stokes and McCullum
Coach Brendon McCullum's Bazball experiment faces its sternest test. England's relaxed demeanor-five days of training ahead of a match that could last fewer days-has drawn both praise and derision. Stokes, doubling as fourth seamer, must balance leadership with performance, particularly against Starc, his most frequent Test nemesis.
Questions linger over team selection. Spinner Will Jacks' recall offers a wildcard option, while Joe Root's drought of centuries in Australia (29 innings without one) looms large. Zak Crawley's form and Jofra Archer's fitness-he has as many Test wins as losses-could prove decisive. A reshuffle of Stokes and Jamie Smith's batting positions has also been mooted.
Stakes beyond the scoreboard
A victory in Brisbane would not only keep the Ashes alive but validate England's unorthodox methods and silence critics. It would also spare the team from a potential holiday backlash, with fans already disillusioned by the Perth defeat. As Stokes noted, "Only a win changes the perception."
For England's players, the next five days could define careers. For the fans, it's a choice between hope and resignation-whether to wake in the winter night or skip the broadcast entirely. The Gabba, a fortress for Australia, awaits its next chapter.
"We can be called rubbish, but not arrogant. We were rubbish in Perth."
Ben Stokes, England captain
