Ask Onix
Smith's costly miss hands Head momentum
England wicketkeeper Jamie Smith failed to hold a sharp edge from Travis Head on day two of the second Ashes Test, a mistake that accelerated Australia's dominance at the Gabba.
Head, who had struggled to just three runs from 25 deliveries when dropped, capitalized immediately. He added 30 runs in his next 17 balls before falling to Brydon Carse at mid-off, having already shifted the match's momentum alongside opener Jake Weatherald.
Smith's Ashes baptism under scrutiny
This series marks Smith's first Ashes appearance, a milestone he prepared for after replacing Ben Foakes and Jonny Bairstow in England's Test lineup earlier this year. While his early career numbers are strong-averaging nearly 47 with the bat-recent form has raised questions.
After a standout 184 not out and 88 against India in July, Smith's highest score in his last seven innings is 33. Fatigue appeared to set in during England's five-Test series against India, with both his batting and glovework suffering as the workload intensified.
The challenge of Australia's conditions
Smith faces a steep learning curve in Australia, where the Gabba's steep bounce and relentless heat test even seasoned keepers. The pink ball-used in this day-night Test-adds another layer of difficulty, despite five training sessions under lights.
His dropped chance came off a Jofra Archer delivery that nipped away from round the wicket, averaging 89.3mph. The ball leapt unexpectedly, catching Smith off guard as it struck high on his gloves before rebounding to the slips.
"That was a beauty from Archer... You've got to take those chances."
Michael Vaughan, former England captain
"It's the worst place in the world to be, having just dropped that catch. He didn't do a lot wrong-just got done for pace and bounce."
Matt Prior, former England wicketkeeper
Carey's brilliance contrasts Smith's struggles
While Smith faltered, Australia's Alex Carey delivered a masterclass behind the stumps. The 34-year-old former Australian Rules footballer made two near-stumpings of Harry Brook and a one-handed catch off a bouncer before producing a full-length dive to dismiss Gus Atkinson.
His most dramatic moment came when he outmuscled Marnus Labuschagne to claim a top-edge from Atkinson, later joking: "Football days, I've had players trying to tag me. Marnus was one of them today... AFL came through there."
Pressure mounts on England's young keeper
Smith's error was just his fourth drop in 58 Test chances, maintaining a 93% catching efficiency-above the 89% average for keepers since 2024. However, three of his four misses have come against left-handed batters, a trend that could haunt England in this series.
Off-field distractions haven't helped. Smith, Ben Stokes, and Mark Wood were photographed riding e-scooters without helmets in Queensland, a legal offense. The incident echoes Carey's own media scrutiny during the 2023 Ashes, when his stumping of Jonny Bairstow sparked controversy.
With four Tests remaining, Smith must quickly adapt to Australia's demands-or risk handing Carey and the hosts a decisive advantage.
