Ask Onix
Independent grocers face uphill battle against retail chains
Alap Vora, owner of Concord Market in Brooklyn, highlights the stark pricing disadvantages small grocery stores face compared to large supermarket chains. A box of cereal that costs him $5 wholesale often retails for the same price at bigger rivals, squeezing already thin margins.
Systemic pricing challenges
Vora, who opened Concord Market in 2009, explains that major chains secure direct relationships with manufacturers, granting them access to preferential pricing. This dynamic leaves independent stores-numbering over 21,000 across the U.S. and accounting for a third of grocery sales-struggling to compete.
"Some customers rent cars to shop at Costco or Trader Joe's because our pricing structure can't match theirs," Vora testified before the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs in May 2024. He described distributor pricing as "fluctuating and opaque," a persistent issue even two years later.
A family business under pressure
Vora's late father launched the family business in 1971 as a Brooklyn gift shop before pivoting to groceries. Despite his own comfort advocating for small businesses-bolstered by his education and U.S. citizenship-he notes that immigrant entrepreneurs like his father often lack the same confidence to speak out.
Cost pressures recently forced Vora to close a second Manhattan location, underscoring the financial strain. "Little has changed since my Senate testimony," he says, surrounded by packed-up inventory in Concord Market's basement office.
Policy debates and potential solutions
Katherine Van Dyck, founder of KVD Strategies, identifies price discrimination as a top concern for small businesses, from grocers to independent bookstores. She advocates for reviving the Robinson-Patman Act, a 1936 law banning sellers from offering preferential prices to select buyers. The Biden administration filed two lawsuits under the act-one against an alcohol distributor (ongoing) and another against PepsiCo (dismissed in 2025).
"When grocers face these pricing dynamics in an industry with razor-thin margins, it makes competition nearly impossible and drives closures," Van Dyck says.
PepsiCo defended its practices, stating it "provides all customers with fair, competitive, and non-discriminatory pricing."
Critics, however, argue that enforcing the Robinson-Patman Act could backfire by raising consumer prices. New York University law professor Daniel Francis suggests alternative support, such as easing tax and regulatory burdens for small retailers. He notes that existing antitrust laws already prohibit suppliers from overcharging smaller rivals.
Calls for transparency and societal support
Vora sees no simple fix but urges greater pricing transparency and communication between small businesses and manufacturers. After struggling to contact PepsiCo and Frito-Lay representatives last year, he questions how less-resourced owners navigate these challenges.
"Society must decide: Is small business critical? Is job creation at this level important? If so, they need more support," he says.
The U.S. Small Business Administration, contacted for comment, did not respond by publication time.
