Ask Onix
Britain faces growing youth disengagement crisis
A recent report reveals nearly one in eight 16- to 24-year-olds in the UK are not in education, employment, or training (Neet), with warnings the figure could rise to one in six within five years without intervention. Former UK health secretary Alan Milburn, who led the study, pointed to the Netherlands as a model for reform, where only 4.9% of 18- to 24-year-olds fall into the Neet category-compared to 15.1% in Britain.
The Dutch 'no dead ends' philosophy
The Netherlands operates on a principle designed to ensure every stage of a young person's education or training leads to a clear outcome. Dutch law mandates school attendance from ages five to 16, followed by compulsory education or training until a qualification is earned or the individual turns 18. This framework, known as the kwalificatieplicht (qualification requirement), aims to eliminate gaps where young people might otherwise disengage.
Streaming and vocational pathways
From around age 12, Dutch students are placed into one of three secondary education tracks based on teacher assessments and primary-school performance. Critics argue this early streaming risks limiting opportunities for some children, but advocates highlight its role in reducing dropout rates. Vocational routes, such as the beroepsbegeleidende leerweg, allow students aged 16 and older to combine part-time work with study, often spending most of the week in employment while attending school one or two days.
"Many skilled tradespeople-electricians, roofers, technicians-earn excellent incomes and are desperately needed by society," said Asja van der Helm, a high school teacher in The Hague. "It's a money-driven society for young adults. When they see a carpenter doing what they like and making a lot of money fast, they see that as aspirational."
Asja van der Helm, high school teacher
Structured flexibility and support networks
Amelie, a 20-year-old from the Netherlands, described her journey through the system as turbulent but ultimately constructive. Initially placed in the vocational VMBO track at age 10, she later struggled to secure an internship and left her fashion course at 17. Unlike in the UK, where dropping out is an option, Dutch law required her to continue until she earned a qualification. She now trains as a teaching assistant at a vocational college in The Hague, crediting the system's flexibility for keeping her engaged.
For students at risk of disengagement, Dutch schools deploy layered support mechanisms. Organisations like Mooi Jong (Beautiful Young), based in The Hague, work with schools to re-engage at-risk pupils. Alexander Koppelle, the organisation's founder, likened the system to a spider's web, where every potential dropout point is met with an intervention-whether through mentorship, alternative programs, or mental health support.
Enforcement and accountability
Dutch schools monitor attendance rigorously. Repeated absences trigger interventions, and truancy can lead to fines, community service, or juvenile supervision. Students unable to attend due to mental health issues are classified as thuis zitters (people sitting at home), with schools retaining funding to provide external support. Meanwhile, the Dutch Employee Insurance Agency (UWV) acts as a one-stop shop for unemployed youth, offering benefits, job-matching services, and career guidance.
Lessons for the UK
While the Dutch model is not without flaws-youth unemployment has risen in recent years-its emphasis on structured pathways and early intervention offers a potential blueprint for the UK. Milburn's report underscores the urgency of reform, noting that England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland lack a unified approach post-16. England requires education or training until 18, but the other nations rely on encouragement rather than legal mandates.
Destiny, who moved to the Netherlands from the Caribbean island of Bonaire, exemplifies the system's strengths. After enrolling in a beauty therapy course, she transitioned seamlessly from an internship to paid employment in a salon. Her story reflects the Dutch goal: ensuring young people remain connected to education or work before becoming fully disengaged.
"I'm not sure we have the golden key," said Koppelle, "but there are lessons to be learned from the Netherlands."
Alexander Koppelle, founder of Mooi Jong
