Ask Onix
Chalamet's comments ignite controversy ahead of Oscars
Timothée Chalamet, once Hollywood's golden boy and a frontrunner for this year's best actor Oscar, has faced a sudden wave of criticism after dismissing ballet and opera as irrelevant. The backlash raises questions about whether the scrutiny is about more than just his remarks.
The remarks that sparked outrage
During a recent interview with Matthew McConaughey-his co-star from the 2014 film Interstellar-Chalamet suggested he didn't want cinema to become a niche interest like ballet or opera. "I don't want to be working in ballet or opera or things where it's like, 'Keep this thing alive even though no-one cares about this anymore,'" he said.
Though he quickly added, "All respect to the ballet and opera people out there," the damage was done. The comment, made over two weeks ago, gained traction last week and snowballed into a full-blown controversy.
Arts community fires back
Theatre critic and broadcaster Ian Brown didn't hold back, calling Chalamet "an absolute fool" on BBC Radio London. "I just think he's ridiculous, and I suspect that will come back to haunt him," Brown said.
US opera singer Isabel Leonard was equally blunt: "To take cheap shots at fellow artists says more in this interview than anything else he could say. Shows a lot about his character."
Some organizations turned the criticism into a marketing opportunity. Seattle Opera offered a 14% discount on Carmen tickets with the promo code TIMOTHEE, adding, "Timmy, you're welcome to use it too."
Was there truth in Chalamet's claim?
While ballet and opera have dedicated audiences, Chalamet's point wasn't entirely baseless. A US arts attendance survey showed opera attendance dropped from 2.2% of the population in 2017 to 0.7% in 2022. Ballet and live dance also declined, from 8.2% to 4.7% over the same period.
Chalamet, whose grandmother, mother, and sister are all dancers, may have spoken from personal experience. However, critics accused him of "punching down" at struggling art forms.
Oscar race impact: Coincidence or smear campaign?
The timing of the backlash-just as Oscar voting closed-fueled speculation. Chalamet's fan account, Club Chalamet, called it a "smear campaign" to hurt his chances. However, Variety's London bureau chief Alex Ritman dismissed the idea, noting the controversy peaked after voting ended and likely had little effect on the outcome.
Chalamet's momentum had already stalled after he lost key awards at the BAFTAs and the Actors Awards. "It's about the momentum as you get into that last leg," Ritman said. "He was obviously a frontrunner for a very long time, and then when all the different award ceremonies start happening back-to-back, you get a lay of the land."
Persona vs. performance: What's hurting Chalamet?
Michael Schulman, author of Oscar Wars, suggested Chalamet's Oscar campaign may have backfired. "He deserves an Oscar, but many people have soured on him a little bit just over the past couple weeks," Schulman said. "I think that has a lot to do with the persona he was putting out there to sell the movie, as this callow youth full of braggadocio."
During the press tour for Marty Supreme, Chalamet leaned into a brash, confident persona that clashed with his later attempts to appear humble. "People had already attached to the Marty Supreme brat persona," Schulman added. "So now he comes off as young and obnoxious, and no-one's going to rush to give a young, obnoxious person the best actor award."
Rehna Azim, awards editor for Movie Marker, defended Chalamet: "I think it's good that Timothée has said something interesting instead of the same bland, safe answers that many actors give. I think he should still get his Oscar. I think he deserves it."
Other factors in the Oscar race
Chalamet's controversy isn't the only drama shaping this year's Oscars. Reports surfaced that a 17-year-old actress was cast as a sex worker in a previous film by Marty Supreme director Josh Safdie, raising ethical concerns. Safdie claimed he was unaware of her age until after filming.
Meanwhile, Sinners star Michael B. Jordan gained support after he and co-star Delroy Lindo handled a disruptive moment at the BAFTAs with grace. A guest with Tourette's involuntarily shouted a racial slur while they were on stage, but the actors remained composed.
Prediction site Gold Derby now gives Jordan a 53% chance of winning best actor, while Chalamet's odds sit at 34%. However, Schulman noted, "He still could win."
Oscar season fatigue
Schulman attributed much of the backlash to the length of the awards season. "Everyone has had too many opportunities to be in front of a microphone talking about whatever's on their mind, and we're running out of things to say," he said.
Irish actress Jessie Buckley, a presumed frontrunner for best actress, also faced minor controversy after joking about getting rid of her cats for defecating on her pillow. Both incidents, Schulman suggested, are symptoms of an overlong Oscar season.
