Ask Onix
Starmer's leadership in peril as cabinet stays silent
UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer faced his most severe leadership challenge on Monday, with senior Labour figures openly questioning his authority and Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar poised to demand his resignation.
By midday, Westminster insiders-including some Downing Street officials-believed Starmer would not survive the day. Energy Secretary Ed Miliband later described the situation as one where MPs had "looked over the precipice" and considered abandoning the prime minister.
Last-minute intervention shifts momentum
The turning point came when Deputy Prime Minister David Lammy posted on X, urging respect for Starmer's "massive mandate." His message triggered a wave of public endorsements from cabinet ministers and MPs, many of whom had remained conspicuously silent earlier.
Behind the scenes, Starmer's team-operating from a makeshift "war room" in the cabinet office-orchestrated a rapid response. Advisers in interim roles after days of turmoil contacted ministers with pre-drafted statements of support, pressuring them to back the prime minister.
"Who does he think he is to try to bring down a Labour government? I like him, but I'm furious," one cabinet minister told reporters, referring to Sarwar's intervention.
Acrimonious calls and unanswered questions
During a tense 1:30 PM call with Sarwar, Starmer reportedly fired back with pointed questions: Who would replace him? How would they improve Labour's prospects? Was there a viable plan?
Similar questions were posed to wavering MPs, forcing them to confront the lack of an obvious alternative. By late afternoon, the tide had turned, though some MPs privately admitted their support was conditional, tied to upcoming electoral tests.
May elections now a critical test
The May local elections-originally significant for devolved governments and councils-have taken on heightened importance in Westminster. Some Labour MPs warn another crisis could erupt within weeks, particularly after the Gorton and Denton by-election, where Labour faces challenges from the Greens and Reform UK.
Health Secretary Streeting at center of speculation
Wes Streeting, the health secretary, emerged as a focal point of tension. His decision to preemptively release WhatsApp messages with Lord Mandelson-bypassing the parliamentary process-sparked accusations of disloyalty. Downing Street swiftly barred other ministers from following suit, issuing a Cabinet Office directive.
While Streeting denied involvement in Sarwar's move, allies of the prime minister alleged his supporters had planned to resign before Monday's Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) meeting-a claim later proven false. The souring relationship between Starmer and Streeting has fueled persistent rumors about the latter's ambitions.
"It shows leadership and is decisive," one supportive MP said of Streeting's WhatsApp release, though others interpreted it as a bid for the top job.
Key figures and a depleted team
Beyond Streeting, other names circulated as potential rivals, including former Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, Defence Secretary John Healey, and Energy Secretary Ed Miliband. However, colleagues largely cited their flaws rather than their suitability, underscoring the lack of a credible challenger.
Starmer's inner circle has been hollowed out, with Chief of Staff Morgan McSweeney and Director of Communications both departing this week. Despite the upheaval, the remaining team earned praise for their rapid mobilization to shore up support.
One imminent change is the expected departure of Cabinet Secretary Sir Chris Wormald, appointed by Starmer in December 2024. Sources at the top of government had already expressed doubts about his fit for the role, given the administration's goal to "rewire the state."
What's next for Starmer's leadership?
While MPs applauded Starmer's defiant speech at Monday's PLP meeting-where he vowed to fight Reform UK and defend "the country that I love"-skepticism remains. One MP noted, "He says he's won every fight he's ever been in. Not true-he's lost every fight he's ever had with the PLP."
Policy flashpoints loom, including reforms to the Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) system. Starmer's ability to navigate these challenges may hinge on his choice of a permanent chief of staff-a decision that could reshape his leadership style.
Miliband urged the prime minister to be "bolder," while others called for a shift to the left. With his team in flux and rivals circling, Starmer's survival may depend on whether he can reconcile his agenda with the party's expectations.
