Ask Onix
Uneasy calm follows brief but intense 2025 clash
Twelve months after a 90-hour military exchange brought India and Pakistan to the brink of wider war, the nuclear-armed neighbors remain locked in a tense standoff that analysts describe as the most brittle equilibrium in decades.
Diplomatic deep freeze
Formal channels between New Delhi and Islamabad have virtually collapsed. The shared border is sealed, bilateral trade has halted, cricket tours are suspended and the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty remains in limbo. Former Pakistani diplomat Husain Haqqani, now at the Anwar Gargash Diplomatic Academy and Hudson Institute, told the BBC the relationship is in "deep freeze," with neither side seeing political incentive to re-engage.
"There have been periods of poor relations before, but this is one of the longest stretches of frozen ties."
Husain Haqqani
Geopolitical ripple effects
The May 2025 conflict reshaped external perceptions of regional power dynamics. Daniel Markey of Johns Hopkins University noted that Pakistan's ability to withstand India's initial strikes challenged the long-held assumption of Indian military dominance. The clash also unexpectedly restored Pakistan's diplomatic relevance, particularly as an intermediary in the Iran crisis.
Christopher Clary, a security expert at the University at Albany, observed that Pakistani leaders are now conducting shuttle diplomacy across the Middle East. However, he cautioned that Islamabad's renewed prominence may hinge on U.S. President Donald Trump's personal diplomatic style and the transient urgency of the Iran situation.
"The shifting sands of Middle East politics are a dangerous game, and working with the Trump administration often brings surprises."
Daniel Markey
U.S. mediation claims strain India ties
Trump's repeated offers to mediate on Kashmir-long rejected by India-and his public praise for Pakistan's army chief, Field Marshal Asim Munir, have strained Washington-New Delhi relations. Michael Kugelman of the Atlantic Council suggested Trump views Pakistan's wartime role as a "David-versus-Goliath" narrative, partly explaining his admiration for Munir.
Ajay Bisaria, India's former high commissioner to Pakistan, argued that the U.S. has lost credibility as a crisis interlocutor, accelerating India's strategic diversification. Since May 2025, Delhi has strengthened ties with the European Union, repaired relations with China and resisted U.S. pressure to distance itself from Russia.
Military lessons and escalation risks
The conflict marked South Asia's first high-tech, drone-centric battle, with no manned aircraft crossing the border. Both countries have since increased defense spending and deepened partnerships with foreign arms suppliers. Yet Clary noted that neither military has fundamentally revised its assessment of the regional balance of power.
Bisaria described the post-conflict environment as a "new normal with strategic ambiguity," warning that future militant attacks could trigger direct retaliation against Pakistan's military. India's suspension of the Indus Waters Treaty underscores its hardened stance, with Bisaria declaring, "Blood and water can't go together."
Pakistan's dual calculus
Islamabad's strategic community appears torn between confidence in its escalation strategy and acute awareness of domestic vulnerabilities. Umer Farooq, an Islamabad-based analyst, told the BBC that Pakistan believes the U.S. and Gulf states would intervene in any future crisis, but economic instability and internal insurgencies temper aggressive posturing.
"Our economy is in a shambles, society is deeply divided, we are facing two insurgencies. There is a mainstream thinking that we should avoid conflict with India."
Umer Farooq
A recent statement by Pakistan's corps commanders, emphasizing "restraint and avoidance of escalation," reflects this cautious approach, according to Farooq.
Prospects for dialogue
Despite the freeze, analysts see limited room for backchannel diplomacy. Markey noted that past backchannel talks have mitigated hostility, while Bisaria suggested Pakistan may eventually seek to "stabilize" the India front if another major attack is averted. Kugelman cautioned that the best near-term outcome may simply be avoiding further deterioration.
Clary emphasized the outsized influence of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Field Marshal Munir, arguing that either leader could revive diplomacy if they chose. For now, however, neither appears inclined to take that step.
