Tech

Robotic hands advance but human-like dexterity remains elusive

Navigation

Ask Onix

Early prototypes to cutting-edge designs

Rich Walker recalls the first robotic hand built by Shadow Robot in the late 1990s, crafted from wood, springs, and rubber bands. Today, the company's latest models feature precision-engineered components, including electric actuators and metal tendons that mimic human finger movements.

At Shadow Robot's north London headquarters, Walker, now a director, demonstrates the evolution. Sensors strapped to fingers translate human gestures into smooth, controlled motions, allowing users to manipulate objects like blocks and cups with surprising accuracy.

Research and real-world applications

Approximately 200 of these robotic hands are currently in use, primarily by university researchers and tech companies. Walker describes them as "development kits for dexterity," enabling users to explore capabilities before scaling up projects.

The demand stems from the need for robots to navigate environments designed for human hands. Bren Pierce, founder of Bristol-based Kinisi, highlights the complexity: "The hand is the hardest, most intricate part of any humanoid robot."

Kinisi's KR1 robots, undergoing commercial trials, use interchangeable grippers-strong pincers for heavy boxes or suction devices for delicate items. Yet, Pierce envisions a single, versatile hand capable of handling all tasks.

The cost and durability challenge

Developing a robust, affordable hand remains a hurdle. Kinisi's prototype three-fingered hand costs £4,000 ($5,400), ten times more than its £400 pincer gripper. Elon Musk identified dexterous hands as one of three major challenges in humanoid robotics, alongside AI comprehension and mass production.

Tesla's upcoming Optimus robot, promised to feature "human-level manual dexterity," faces skepticism. Nathan Lepora, Professor of Robotics and AI at Bristol University, dismisses near-term claims: "It won't happen in two years, but we might see progress in a decade."

Innovations in design and sensing

Lepora's research, funded by the UK's Aria scheme, focuses on tendon-driven hands. However, he praises Chinese firms like Wuji Technology for integrating motors directly into fingers, achieving intricate movements with four independently controlled joints per digit.

Wuji's hands, priced at $12,000 (£8,800), include piezoelectric sensors for touch feedback. Co-founder Yunzhe Pan promises improved durability and affordability in future models.

Touch sensing remains a critical frontier. Pierce notes that while lab sensors perform well, industrial durability is lacking: "I want robots to work for 10 years, not six months."

Optimism amid obstacles

Despite challenges, Lepora sees progress driven by massive investment in humanoid robotics. "Historically, tactile sensing seemed perpetually a decade away. Now, things are changing," he says.

"Everyone has dreamed for 40 years of one robot hand to rule them all. A lot of people think it could be the humanoid hand."

Bren Pierce, Kinisi Founder

Related posts

Report a Problem

Help us improve by reporting any issues with this response.

Problem Reported

Thank you for your feedback

Ed