Ask Onix
Premier League title decided by new rules: Who comes out on top?
Arsenal ended a 22-year wait for the Premier League trophy this season, but what if the title had been awarded using different performance metrics? BBC Sport and Opta analyzed the 2025-26 campaign through alternative lenses, revealing surprising outcomes for several clubs.
Expected points: The analytical approach
While real points determine the league table, expected points (xPTS) offer insight into whether teams overperformed or underperformed based on the quality of chances created and conceded. This metric calculates the likelihood of points earned from match situations, providing a theoretical league table.
The most dramatic outlier was Sunderland, who would have faced relegation under xPTS despite surviving in reality. Aston Villa would have finished in the bottom half, while Chelsea would have secured Champions League qualification. These discrepancies raise questions about the predictive power of expected data.
Home vs. away: The fortress effect
Some teams thrived on the road but struggled in front of their own fans. Tottenham, for example, earned enough away points to qualify for the Europa League-had only road trips counted. Everton and Nottingham Forest also performed significantly better away from home, defying expectations given their fans' reputation for creating intense atmospheres.
Fulham, however, excelled at Craven Cottage, where their home form outshone their away results. The west London club's cozy stadium proved a genuine advantage in this alternative assessment.
Set-pieces: The season's defining trend
The 2025-26 Premier League was dominated by set-piece goals, fouls, and the rise of specialized coaches-often recognizable by their tracksuits and long hair. Arsenal were among the best performers from dead-ball situations, sparking debate about whether clubs will prioritize set-piece mastery in the summer transfer window.
Will teams invest in free-kick specialists and towering targets, or will a more fluid attacking style re-emerge next season?
Long-range goals: The spectacular table
For fans of thunderous strikes, an alternative league table based solely on goals scored from outside the box offers a fresh perspective. This metric highlights teams that excelled in producing moments of individual brilliance rather than structured build-up play.
English goals only: A Three Lions twist
With England preparing for a major tournament, what if the Premier League had ranked teams based only on goals scored by English players? This hypothetical scenario would have reshaped the table, emphasizing domestic talent over international contributions. Would it have changed the title race or European qualification spots?
The exercise serves as a reminder of how different metrics can tell contrasting stories about a season's true narrative.
