Ask Onix
Pentagon's war narrative takes center stage
Since the U.S. and Israel launched strikes on Iran, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has dominated Pentagon briefings with a televised-style delivery, framing the conflict as a display of American military dominance. His remarks-ranging from declarations of "a capital V military victory" to descriptions of "death and destruction from the sky"-have set the tone for public perception, even as the war's true impact remains contested.
Shifting objectives and unmet goals
President Trump's initial war aim was to dismantle Iran's nuclear capabilities, a goal he claimed was achieved after bombing sites in Isfahan, Fordow, and Natanz. Yet Iran retains its stockpile of near-weapons-grade uranium, buried under rubble. Rafael Grossi, head of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), has warned that military action cannot resolve Iran's nuclear ambitions. Trump now pledges to "dig up and remove all... Nuclear Dust," but Tehran's defiance suggests negotiations in Islamabad will be pivotal.
Regime change, another early objective, has also stalled. While Israel killed Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, his son Mojtaba succeeded him, and Iran's leadership remains intact. Trump's comparison to Venezuela-where he detained President Nicolás Maduro-has not materialized in Tehran.
Disputed claims and military toll
U.S. officials assert they've "obliterated" Iran's conventional arsenal, including missiles, drones, and naval assets. However, leaked intelligence disputes this, estimating Iran retains roughly half its pre-war stockpile. The BBC has not independently verified either claim.
The human and financial costs are clearer: 13 U.S. service members killed, hundreds wounded, and munitions expended at an unprecedented rate, including Tomahawk missiles. The daily price tag exceeds $1 billion, straining military resources.
Political fractures and economic fallout
Domestically, Trump faces backlash. Polls show minority support for the war, and his party is divided. Former allies like Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene have condemned his threats as "evil," while Democrats demand answers about a suspected U.S. missile strike on a school in Minab that killed 168 civilians, including 110 children. The Pentagon's investigation, now six weeks old, has yielded no findings.
The economic repercussions are already visible. The Strait of Hormuz's closure has spiked fuel prices, with ripple effects expected at grocery stores. Analysts warn this could sway November's midterms, potentially costing Republicans control of Congress.
Alliances strained, global power shifts
Trump's erratic stance on reopening the Strait-vacillating between demanding allied support and dismissing them as "cowards"-has deepened NATO's divisions. European nations are accelerating efforts to reduce dependence on the U.S., a strategic boon for China. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte described recent White House talks as "very frank," a diplomatic euphemism for tension.
As ceasefire talks continue, the war's long-term costs remain uncertain. Critics argue Trump's approach has weakened America's global standing, while his administration insists it forced Iran's capitulation. The verdict may ultimately rest with voters in November.
"This is not making America great again, this is evil."
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA)
"Never underestimate President Trump's ability to successfully advance America's interests and broker peace."
White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt
