Ask Onix
Five years after legalisation, New York's cannabis industry faces growing pains
New York's legal cannabis market, now five years old, is grappling with a paradox: while marijuana appears ubiquitous across the state, legitimate businesses are fighting to survive against a thriving grey market and a fragmented legal landscape.
Visible boom masks underlying challenges
From neon-lit dispensaries in Manhattan to corner stores advertising unregulated products, cannabis has become a fixture of New York's urban landscape. The scent of marijuana is so pervasive that even athletes at the US Open have complained. Yet behind the apparent boom, legal operators warn of an industry in distress.
Public skepticism is mounting. Social media is flooded with criticism, with many arguing that New York's rollout of legal weed has been botched. The New York Times, once a vocal supporter of legalisation, recently published an editorial titled "Marijuana Is Everywhere. That's a Problem." The newspaper now contends that cannabis is causing more harm than anticipated and calls for stricter regulations.
Legal operators blame illicit market for struggles
Jayson Tantalo, vice president of operations for the New York Cannabis Retail Association, describes a market distorted by unlicensed sellers. "At first glance, New York's cannabis industry appears to be booming," he says. "But that perception was initially driven by an oversaturation of illicit operators."
These unregulated shops, often posing as legitimate businesses, have created a misleading impression of economic success while undercutting licensed retailers. The state's slow licensing process exacerbated the problem, leaving legal growers with unsold crops and paving the way for hundreds of grey-market outlets, particularly in New York City.
Enforcement ramps up as legal market expands
State authorities are now cracking down on illegal operators, granting police the power to shut unlicensed shops immediately. Vlad Bautista, co-founder of Manhattan-based cannabis retailer Happy Munkey, acknowledges some progress but warns the battle is far from over. "It made a little dent," he says of recent enforcement efforts. "But there's still a long way to go."
Despite the challenges, the legal market is growing. CRB Monitor, a cannabis industry research firm, reports over 2,000 active licenses in New York, with nearly 5,000 more applications pending. Dispensaries are now appearing across the state, from suburban Victor-where Tantalo and his wife operate Flower City Dispensary-to upstate Gloversville, home to Veterans Holdings, a business founded by Iraq War veteran Jason Ambrosino.
Federal contradictions complicate state-level legalisation
New York's struggles reflect broader national confusion. While public support for legalisation has surged-Gallup polling shows two-thirds of Americans now favor it-cannabis remains illegal under federal law, classified as a Schedule I drug. This creates a patchwork of state regulations, with neighboring states often holding opposing policies.
A road trip from New York to the West Coast would pass through states where marijuana is alternately legal and banned, creating logistical nightmares for businesses and consumers alike. The 2018 Farm Bill, which legalized hemp with low THC levels, further muddied the waters by enabling grey-market businesses to sell psychoactive products under the guise of hemp.
"Entrepreneurs could say, 'this is just hemp,' even if what they were producing was a highly intoxicating form of THC,"
Chris Lindsay, American Trade Association for Cannabis and Hemp
Business owners navigate regulatory hurdles and financial barriers
Legal cannabis businesses face a web of restrictions. Ambrosino, whose company employs around 80 people, cites federal banking laws as a major obstacle. "There's a million different ways to get institutional funding, but you can't get any of those for cannabis," he says.
Advertising rules are equally restrictive. Bautista estimates he spends 40% of his time on compliance, noting that cannabis businesses face stricter marketing regulations than alcohol, tobacco, or gambling companies. "You're stuck in the stone age, handing out flyers on the street," he says.
A December executive order by President Trump, directing officials to reclassify marijuana, sparked optimism in the industry. However, experts like Naomi Granger of the National Association of Cannabis Accounting and Tax Professionals dismiss the move as largely symbolic. "It's smoke and mirrors," she says, warning that headlines have overstated the potential impact.
Optimism persists despite obstacles
Despite the headwinds, some industry leaders remain hopeful. Steve Kemmerling of CRB Monitor draws parallels to early legal markets in California and Colorado, which faced similar volatility before stabilizing. "In any new market you're going to have wild swings and people cutting corners," he says.
Bautista echoes this cautious optimism. "We live in a divided world where nobody agrees on everything, but there's a majority who agree on legal cannabis," he says. "We've made a ton of progress, but there's still a long way to go."
