Ask Onix
Kepa's mistake proves decisive in Arsenal's Carabao Cup final defeat
Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta faced immediate backlash after his decision to start second-choice goalkeeper Kepa Arrizabalaga in Sunday's Carabao Cup final backfired, as a handling error directly led to Manchester City's opening goal.
The error that changed the game
Kepa failed to secure Rayan Cherki's cross in the 12th minute, allowing 18-year-old Nico O'Reilly to head City into the lead. The young midfielder doubled the advantage just four minutes later, and City never relinquished control, securing a 2-0 victory at Wembley.
Arteta's choice to field Kepa over first-choice David Raya-who leads the Premier League with 15 clean sheets this season-drew sharp criticism, particularly after City's backup goalkeeper, James Trafford, produced a standout performance to deny Arsenal's attack.
Arteta defends his decision
Despite the fallout, Arteta stood by his selection, calling it "honest and fair" to reward Kepa for his contributions throughout the tournament. The Spain international had started every prior round of the competition.
"I understand the scrutiny, but I have to do what I feel is right. Errors are part of football, and today it happened in a crucial moment."
Mikel Arteta
Arteta added that he never guarantees players specific roles, emphasizing that opportunities must be earned in training.
Critics question Arteta's sentimentality
Former players and pundits weighed in, with ex-England goalkeeper Joe Hart stating bluntly: "Don't ever feel sorry for a goalkeeper. That's the life he's chosen."
European football analyst Julien Laurens was equally direct, arguing that Arsenal's trophy drought since 2020 demanded pragmatism. "There is no moment for sentiment," he said. "Your best team has to play."
Chris Sutton, a former Premier League striker, echoed the sentiment on BBC Radio 5 Live: "I never understand why managers play second-choice goalkeepers in cup finals. You're trying to win a trophy-why wouldn't you play your number one?"
Kepa's history of final heartbreak
The defeat marked Kepa's third consecutive Carabao Cup final loss. In 2019, while playing for Chelsea, he infamously refused to be substituted before a penalty shootout. Three years later, he missed a decisive spot-kick in another final against Liverpool.
His latest error-a misjudged clearance that led to a booking moments before conceding-further cemented his reputation for struggling in high-stakes matches.
Trafford's redemption offers contrast
While Kepa faltered, Trafford's performance provided a stark counterpoint. Signed by City as their intended number one in the summer, Trafford became the backup after the club acquired Gianluigi Donnarumma from Paris Saint-Germain.
The 22-year-old made a trio of early saves to deny Kai Havertz and Bukayo Saka, setting the tone for City's dominance. "Those saves happened so quickly, I can't even remember them," Trafford said post-match. "I'm just happy to play my part."
Guardiola's pre-match confirmation of Trafford's starting role underscored the manager's faith in the young keeper, who described the victory as a "testament to how I believed in myself."
What's next for Arsenal?
With the Premier League title race still alive, Arteta and his squad must regroup quickly. The Carabao Cup loss, however, leaves a bitter taste-one that may linger as Arsenal chase their first major trophy in six years.
