Ask Onix
Pandas return to China amid diplomatic standoff
Tokyo's Ueno Zoo bid farewell to giant pandas Xiao Xiao and Lei Lei last month after Beijing ordered their repatriation, marking the first time in decades Japan has been left without any Chinese pandas on its soil. The move is part of a broader campaign by China to pressure Japan following controversial comments by Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi on Taiwan, analysts say.
Takaichi's Taiwan remarks spark crisis
Tensions erupted in November when Takaichi suggested Japan could activate its self-defense forces in response to a potential attack on Taiwan. China, which claims Taiwan as its territory and reserves the right to use force for "reunification," reacted with fury, demanding an immediate retraction. Takaichi refused, doubling down on her stance despite Beijing's escalating retaliation.
While previous Japanese leaders have expressed similar views, Takaichi's remarks marked the first time a sitting prime minister had articulated them publicly. Her unyielding position has been bolstered by a decisive electoral victory in a recent snap election, which analysts say has emboldened her to stand firm against Chinese pressure.
China's multi-front pressure campaign
Beijing has responded with a sweeping array of measures targeting Japan's economy, military, and cultural ties. Diplomatically, China has lodged complaints with the United Nations, postponed a trilateral summit with Japan and South Korea, and urged Western allies like the UK and France to condemn Tokyo. At the Munich Security Conference over the weekend, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi invoked Japan's wartime history, calling Takaichi's remarks a "very dangerous development."
Militarily, Japan has reported increased Chinese activity near its borders, including drones, warships, and fighter jets locking radar on Japanese aircraft. Coast guard vessels from both nations have clashed near the disputed Senkaku/Diaoyu islands, and Japanese authorities recently seized a Chinese fishing boat in the area.
Economically, China has restricted exports of rare earth elements and critical minerals to Japan, a move widely seen as economic coercion. Beijing has also discouraged Chinese tourism to Japan, canceling 49 flight routes and warning citizens against traveling there. Chinese tourists account for a quarter of all foreign visitors to Japan, and the drop has already impacted local businesses and stock markets.
Culture and entertainment caught in the crossfire
China's pressure extends to Japan's cultural exports. Music events have been canceled, including one where a Japanese singer was abruptly removed from the stage mid-performance. Film distributors have postponed the release of several Japanese movies, and an event featuring the popular franchise Pokémon was scrapped after it was scheduled to take place at Tokyo's Yasukuni Shrine, which honors Japan's war dead-including figures China considers war criminals.
On social media, Chinese nationalists have targeted Takaichi with AI-generated videos depicting pop culture icons like Ultraman and Detective Conan attacking her. Despite the provocations, analysts note that China's actions have been relatively restrained compared to past conflicts, suggesting room for further escalation.
Analysts warn of prolonged tensions
Experts agree that the current standoff is unlikely to de-escalate soon. Robert Ward of the International Institute for Strategic Studies described China's strategy as "greyzone warfare," aimed at normalizing what he called "abnormal" pressure tactics. Bonny Lin and Kristi Govella of the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) warned that while China's economic and military responses have been limited so far, there is "ample room for further escalation."
China's restraint may stem from its efforts to position itself as a responsible global power, particularly in contrast to the U.S. However, Taiwan remains a "core interest" for Beijing, and analysts say China is unlikely to soften its stance. "Beijing is deeply suspicious of Takaichi and views her attempts to de-escalate without retracting her comments as hypocritical or strategically deceptive," Lin and Govella noted in a recent analysis.
For Japan, Takaichi's electoral mandate has reinforced her resolve. She has pledged to accelerate defense spending to 2% of GDP, revise key security strategies by year's end, and launch an economic stimulus package. Kiyoteru Tsutsui of Stanford University suggested that China may avoid intensifying pressure further, fearing it could strengthen Takaichi's domestic support.
The U.S. wildcard
The role of the U.S. adds another layer of complexity. President Donald Trump has publicly endorsed Takaichi, but analysts expect U.S.-China relations to warm this year, with multiple meetings planned between Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping, including a state visit to Beijing in April. The relatively muted U.S. response to the latest spat has raised concerns in Tokyo about a potential "grand bargain" between Washington and Beijing.
"The Japanese are terrified there's going to be some grand bargain between Xi and Trump," Ward said. To counter this, Japan is likely to deepen its defense cooperation with the U.S. and take on a larger share of the regional security burden. Takaichi is scheduled to meet Trump in Washington next month, ahead of his trip to China.
As the standoff continues, analysts predict that even if tensions ease, they will settle at a higher level than before. "This tango will likely continue for a while," Tsutsui said, with both sides digging in for a prolonged struggle.
