Ask Onix
Islamabad prepares for critical US-Iran negotiations
Pakistan's capital is set to host pivotal discussions between Washington and Tehran this week, with both sides expressing cautious optimism despite deep-seated obstacles. Security measures are in place, and officials from Islamabad have highlighted their unique position as a trusted mediator for both parties.
Key figures project optimism, but warnings loom
US Vice-President JD Vance struck a hopeful tone ahead of his departure, stating, "If the Iranians are willing to negotiate in good faith, we're certainly willing to extend the open hand." However, he issued a stern caveat: "If they're going to try to play us, then they're going to find the negotiating team is not that receptive."
Iran's President Masoud Pezeshkian, meanwhile, has tied the success of the talks to Israel's actions in Lebanon. In a post on X, he declared, "The continuation of these actions will render negotiations meaningless. Our fingers remain on the trigger. Iran will never abandon its Lebanese sisters and brothers."
Hezbollah conflict threatens to derail discussions
Israel's ongoing military campaign against Hezbollah, Iran's ally in Lebanon, casts a long shadow over the talks. While Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu insists there will be "no ceasefire," Israel has yet to escalate its warnings to residents of Beirut's southern suburbs into further action.
US President Donald Trump suggested Israel's operations in Lebanon would become "a little more low key," and the State Department announced direct Israel-Lebanon talks in Washington next week. Whether this shift will satisfy Iran remains uncertain.
Strait of Hormuz emerges as flashpoint
Another potential dealbreaker is Iran's control over the Strait of Hormuz, a critical oil shipping route. Trump accused Iran of failing to uphold its initial commitments, calling its actions "dishonourable" in a Truth Social post. Few vessels are currently passing through the strait, leaving hundreds of ships and an estimated 20,000 seafarers stranded in the Gulf.
Iran has tightened its grip on the waterway, declaring it sovereign territory and announcing new transit rules. On Thursday, it introduced alternative routes north of existing traffic lanes, citing the need to "avoid the presence of various types of anti-ship mines in the main traffic zone." Reports suggest some ships that traversed the strait in recent weeks paid a $2 million toll, prompting Trump to warn Iran against imposing fees on tankers.
Nuclear dispute remains central hurdle
The long-standing nuclear standoff looms largest over the talks. Trump launched "Operation Epic Fury" partly to ensure Iran "can never have a nuclear weapon." Iran, however, maintains it has no intention of building a bomb, though Western governments remain skeptical. Tehran insists its uranium enrichment-permitted under the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty-is for civilian purposes only.
Iran's 10-point proposal, which Trump called "a workable basis on which to negotiate," includes a demand for international recognition of its enrichment rights. The US, meanwhile, reportedly seeks a complete halt to uranium enrichment on Iranian soil. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth clarified this week that the US goal is to prevent Iran from acquiring "a nuclear weapon or the capability to get a path to one."
The 2015 Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) took years to negotiate, and it remains unclear whether both sides are prepared to revisit such a complex agreement.
Regional alliances and economic pressures add complexity
Iran's network of regional allies-Hezbollah in Lebanon, the Houthis in Yemen, Hamas in Gaza, and militias in Iraq-has bolstered its influence, enabling what Tehran calls "forward defense" against Israel and the US. Since the Gaza war began in October 2023, this "Axis of Resistance" has faced relentless attacks, with Syria's Assad regime already toppled.
Israel views the alliance as an existential threat and seeks its eradication. Domestically, many Iranians are pressing their government to reduce foreign spending and address economic struggles. However, Iran shows no signs of abandoning its proxies.
The Islamic Republic, under decades of sanctions, is demanding the lifting of all US and international restrictions as part of any deal. On Friday, Parliament Speaker Mohammad Bagher Qalibaf insisted that $120 billion in frozen Iranian assets must be released before negotiations begin, citing a prior agreement. However, Pakistan's April 7 ceasefire announcement made no mention of such a condition, leaving the claim's validity unclear.
The Trump administration is unlikely to concede such a significant demand merely to initiate talks.
