Ask Onix
Automation reshapes India's job market
A control center in Navi Mumbai exemplifies the shift: 100 operators now monitor 30,000 ATMs using AI and sensors, replacing 60,000 security guards. This transformation extends beyond banking, quietly eliminating roles that once sustained India's middle class.
Graduates struggle as white-collar jobs decline
Engineering and commerce graduates, once assured of stable employment, now face a stark reality. White-collar job growth has plummeted from 11% before 2020 to just 1% today, according to the Naukri Jobspeak Index. Automation, long a threat to clerical and sales roles, has accelerated with AI, particularly in India's IT sector-the largest employer of graduates, with eight million workers.
Government projections from Niti Aayog warn that AI could displace nearly three million IT and customer service jobs by 2031. Executives at major firms openly discuss plans to cut salary costs by a third using AI tools. At one private bank, a single AI system now handles 95% of customer queries, a task previously managed by a 3,000-person call center.
Economic pressures push middle class into debt
VS, a 27-year-old BTech graduate from Rajasthan, earns 14,000 rupees ($151) monthly as a freelance salesperson. Last year, he lost 1.3 million rupees-nearly his family's entire savings-trading futures and options (F&O). He is among nine million Indians engaging in such trades, collectively losing over $12 billion annually, equivalent to India's federal education budget.
Rahul Singh, a food delivery worker, borrowed money not only for home renovations but also to cover rent, medical bills, and other essentials. Their stories reflect a broader trend: India's middle class, comprising 40 million income taxpayers earning between 500,000 and 10 million rupees annually, is under unprecedented financial strain.
Cost of living outpaces income growth
Over the past decade, the average middle-class income has risen by just 50,000 rupees-roughly the cost of a smartphone. Meanwhile, living expenses have surged. A vegetarian thali now costs 11% more each year, entry-level vehicles rise by 7-8% annually, and medical costs climb at 14%. Estimates suggest the true cost of living for middle-class households doubles every eight years, implying an effective inflation rate of 9%.
A family comfortable on 1 million rupees in 2016 would now need nearly 2 million rupees annually to maintain the same lifestyle. Yet salaries have stagnated, leaving many trapped in a cycle of debt. Non-housing household debt as a share of income now exceeds levels in the U.S. and China, with 67% of borrowers taking their first loan before age 30. Nearly 40% of their income goes toward servicing debt, and 5-10% are caught in a debt trap, borrowing to repay existing loans.
Economic slowdown ripples through consumer markets
The financial squeeze is visible in consumer behavior. Fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) volume growth has dropped from 11% to 3% over the past 14 years, while car sales and consumer durables growth have stagnated. Executives at major consumer companies describe a stunned realization: Indians are spending less not by choice, but necessity.
This decline matters beyond household budgets. Consumption drives 60% of India's GDP. The post-1991 growth model relied on a virtuous cycle: middle-class spending created demand, demand generated jobs, and jobs fueled further spending. That cycle has fractured.
Education no longer guarantees opportunity
India produces over eight million graduates annually, yet unemployment among them stands at 29.1%-nine times higher than for those without formal education. Even elite institutions like IIT Bombay report that 8,000 of 21,500 graduates remain unemployed. The IIT degree, once a guaranteed path to prosperity, now resembles a lottery.
In Pune's Hinjewadi tech park, young engineers with degrees and debt line up daily for walk-in interviews at BPO firms, hoping for data entry jobs paying 18,000 rupees monthly. This is the new reality for India's educated middle class.
Political neglect and an uncertain future
Despite its size-40 million taxpayers among 970 million voters-the middle class lacks political representation. Policymakers prioritize the poor for votes and the wealthy for funding, leaving the middle class to bear the fiscal burden without influence.
The authors of Breakpoint: The Crisis of the Middle Class and the Future of Work, Saurabh Mukherjea and Nandita Rajhansa, argue that the middle class built post-reform India. Whether the country can sustain this class in the coming decade remains the defining question of the era.
