Ask Onix
The Villages: A retiree's paradise with a growing rift
Spanning 30,000 acres in central Florida, The Villages bills itself as the world's largest retirement community-a meticulously planned haven for those over 55, packed with golf courses, live music, and a fleet of colorful golf carts. But beneath the sun-soaked social scene, political tensions have surged since Donald Trump's return to the White House last year.
A lifestyle built for leisure
Residents describe the sprawling development, which spans three counties and four ZIP codes, as a full-time resort. North Carolina transplant Betty Brock, 79, tells friends back home that boredom here is a personal failing. "It's like being at a resort on a full-time basis," she says.
Terri Emery, 62, calls it "utopia." On a recent evening, she dined at a steakhouse while live music pulsed from one of the community's five town squares. Nearby, neighbors danced to covers of Livin' La Vida Loca and Man! I Feel Like a Woman, their golf carts-decorated with flags and bumper stickers-parked in neat rows.
"You move here to be young; you don't move here to die and become old," Emery says.
Politics disrupts the harmony
Trump's upcoming rally on Friday has exposed deep divisions in a community long known as a Republican stronghold. While supporters scramble for tickets, Democrats are organizing protests, and both sides agree: politics is now a topic best avoided.
"Everybody does still try to get along," says Maddy Bacher, 63, a Democrat from Connecticut. "You want to at least be able to say good morning and how's the dog. But... I find you don't socialize as much."
Brock, a Trump voter, admits politics comes up, but "not as much as you think, because you don't ever know where that line is."
A microcosm of national tensions
Founded in the 1970s, The Villages has reliably backed Trump in all three of his presidential bids. Yet last month's "No Kings" protest-drawing nearly 7,000 people across two locations-signaled a shift. Democratic Club president Bill Knudson, who moved here four years ago, was stunned by the turnout at a post-inauguration meeting.
"They had to go out of their way to find us,"
Bill Knudson, Democratic Club president
While Trump's visit has energized his base, it's also stoked anxiety. Traffic snarls and security lines are expected to disrupt the usual golf-cart commutes, keeping some residents home regardless of their politics.
Divided clubs and fractured friendships
The political divide has reshaped social life. Bacher started a Democrats-only pickleball game after leaving a clay club over a dispute about COVID boosters. Her husband launched a Democratic golf group to avoid right-leaning banter on the course.
Tom Samson, 81, a retired pest control owner, praises Trump's unfiltered style. "He doesn't have a filter and says whatever's on his mind, and he's not a politician," he says. But such cross-aisle conversations are rare, residents say.
Bob Carberry, who moved here 14 years ago, recalls an almost "apolitical" past. "The emotional level of politics is something that's emerged probably more so in the last five years with Trump," he says.
Trump's visit: A lightning rod for passion and protest
For supporters, the rally is the event of the year. "He's a man that does what he says he's going to do," says Sharlene, who declined to give her last name. She'll miss the speech due to work but plans to join a watch party.
Phil Montalvo, 79, a retired lawyer, dismisses Democratic activism. "We're not sitting on our laurels, but we're not intimidated by that at all," he says, citing Sumter County's 77,000 registered Republicans versus 23,000 Democrats.
Others are less diplomatic. Emery calls protesters "communists" and insists, "The only king is the Lord."
Seeking middle ground in a polarized paradise
Not all residents have picked a side. Edward Hannan, 77, a lawyer, won't attend the rally, citing long lines and security hassles. "I disagree with him on many things, but there are certain things that I like," he says of Trump. "You should not denigrate people who disagree with you; you should reason with them."
Hannan laments the lack of political dialogue in The Villages, where conversations are either avoided or confined to like-minded circles. When asked if his centrist views make him an outlier, he doesn't hesitate: "Yes."
Roy Irwin, 82, who met his partner Susan Prince at church 14 years ago, tries to keep discussions civil. "It's really a microcosm of the country," he says. "There's people [feeling] very strongly on both sides."
