Ask Onix
Why we often fail as friends without realizing it
Most people believe they are good friends, yet rarely recognize how their own flaws affect those closest to them. Research shows that thoughtless actions-even unintentional ones-can harm relationships more than outright hostility. A growing body of evidence reveals simple but effective strategies to avoid becoming an "accidental frenemy."
The stress of uncertainty in friendships
Neuroscience research demonstrates how unpredictability heightens anxiety. In a study led by Archy de Berker at University College London, participants played a computer game where they received mild electric shocks after finding virtual snakes. Surprisingly, stress responses were strongest when the probability of a shock was 50%-far more intense than when shocks were certain.
This principle applies to friendships. Studies define "ambivalent relationships" as those that provoke mixed feelings-helpful in some moments, upsetting in others. Simply knowing an unpredictable friend is nearby has been shown to raise blood pressure, illustrating the physical toll of emotional inconsistency.
The solution? Strive for reliability. Managing personal moods can prevent lashing out at friends during bad moments, reducing the emotional whiplash they experience.
The illusion of transparency and its consequences
People often assume others can read their emotions, a cognitive bias known as the "illusion of transparency." This misconception leads to under-communication, leaving friends feeling undervalued. For example, job candidates frequently believe their nervousness is obvious, when in reality, interviewers may not notice.
A study by Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley found that people consistently underestimate how much a simple thank-you note will surprise and delight its recipient. While body language can convey warmth, verbal expressions of appreciation are far more effective at strengthening bonds.
How to support friends during tough times
Empathy is crucial when friends face difficulties, but dismissive or judgmental responses can deepen their distress. However, agreeing with their perspective isn't always necessary. Research suggests that encouraging reflection-rather than just venting-helps people gain closure.
Psychologist Ethan Kross recommends asking questions like:
- "What made this situation particularly stressful for you?"
- "Have you learned anything from this experience?"
- "Does looking at the bigger picture change how you view this?"
These prompts help friends reframe their problems, reducing long-term emotional strain.
The power of celebrating others' successes
While compassion for hardship is widely recognized, "confelicity"-sharing in others' joy-is equally vital. Studies show that how friends respond to good news matters just as much as their reactions to bad news. Active, enthusiastic responses (e.g., asking for details, expressing pride) strengthen relationships, while passive or dismissive reactions weaken them.
Similarly, hiding personal achievements can backfire. Research by Annabelle Roberts, Emma Levine, and Övül Sezer found that people often feel offended when friends conceal promotions or milestones, perceiving it as a lack of trust or warmth.
The art of a meaningful apology
Many avoid apologizing due to misconceptions: fear of shame, doubt about its effectiveness, or uncertainty about what to say. However, psychological research identifies four key components of an effective apology:
- Allow the hurt person to express their feelings.
- Acknowledge responsibility for the offense.
- Express genuine regret.
- Explain how you'll prevent future mistakes.
Contrary to fears, apologies often bring relief and rebuild trust more effectively than expected.
Putting it all together
No friendship is perfect, but small adjustments can prevent common pitfalls. By prioritizing reliability, expressing appreciation, offering constructive support, celebrating successes, and apologizing sincerely, anyone can become the kind of friend they'd want for themselves.
"Every relationship has ups and downs, but science offers clear ways to avoid the most damaging mistakes," says science writer David Robson, author of The Laws of Connection.
