Ask Onix
Ferrari unveils first electric vehicle amid controversy
Ferrari's inaugural electric car, the Luce, has drawn sharp criticism from investors, politicians, and longtime fans since its high-profile debut. The $640,000 five-seater, designed in collaboration with former iPhone designer Sir Jony Ive, marks a dramatic shift for the brand, which has long resisted electrification.
Launch met with skepticism and memes
The unveiling, attended by Italian President Sergio Mattarella and Pope Leo, was overshadowed by an immediate 8% drop in Ferrari's share price. Social media erupted with mockery, comparing the Luce to budget EVs like the Nissan Leaf and circulating AI-generated redesigns that critics claimed surpassed Ferrari's own efforts.
Shaun Baker, an Australia-based luxury car dealer and collector, dubbed the car the "Loser," arguing it undermines Ferrari's aspirational image. "They've hurt their brand," he told the BBC.
Critics question Ferrari's identity
Former Ferrari chairman Luca Cordero di Montezemolo warned the Luce risks "destroying a legend" and suggested removing the iconic prancing horse badge. Italy's Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini echoed the sentiment, questioning what founder Enzo Ferrari would think of the design, which he called "anything but a Ferrari."
The Luce's performance-0-60 mph in 2.5 seconds and a top speed over 190 mph-matches traditional supercars, but its electric powertrain lacks the brand's signature engine roar, and its taller profile deviates from Ferrari's low-slung aesthetic.
Industry shifts and Chinese competition
Ferrari's pivot to EVs comes as global automakers reassess their electric strategies. Lamborghini scrapped its EV program due to weak demand, while Porsche, Ford, and Honda have scaled back production. Meanwhile, Chinese carmakers, backed by aggressive subsidies and cost-efficient supply chains, are flooding the market with affordable, high-performance EVs like the $250,000 BYD Yangwang U9, which accelerates faster than the Luce.
Jessica Cheam, a sustainable industry expert, noted the Luce's "eye-popping price tag" is hard to justify amid cheaper, equally luxurious alternatives. However, Ferrari CEO Benedetto Vigna defended the cost as necessary for innovation, citing strong early interest from buyers.
Targeting a new audience
Analysts suggest the Luce may appeal to younger, EV-friendly consumers rather than Ferrari's traditional base. Singapore car analyst James Wong praised the interior but called the exterior "unrecognizable" as a Ferrari. He questioned whether the company conducted market research with loyal customers before the launch.
"All this could have been intentional," Wong added, pointing to the media storm surrounding the car. "Ferrari might be betting on controversy to attract new buyers."
Ferrari's history of bold moves
This isn't the first time Ferrari has courted backlash. The 2022 Purosangue SUV, initially criticized for diluting the brand's exclusivity, became a commercial success. Similarly, Jaguar's 2024 EV concept, the Type 00, faced accusations of abandoning its heritage, though CEO Rawdon Glover defended the design as "bold and disruptive."
Ferrari has not responded to requests for comment on the Luce's reception. The car's long-term impact on the brand's reputation remains uncertain as the industry navigates a turbulent transition to electrification.
