Ask Onix
EU and India finalize landmark trade deal after decades of stalemate
The European Union and India concluded negotiations on Tuesday for a comprehensive trade agreement, ending two decades of deadlock. The deal, still subject to ratification, reflects both economic ambitions and geopolitical maneuvering as global trade dynamics shift.
Economic ties deepen amid geopolitical tensions
The EU remains India's largest trading partner, with bilateral goods trade reaching $142.3 billion in 2024-accounting for 11.5% of India's total trade. India ranks as the EU's ninth-largest partner. Despite these strong figures, negotiations had stalled for years until recent geopolitical pressures accelerated progress.
Trump's tariff policies spur global realignment
Analysts cite the unpredictability of the U.S. under President Donald Trump as a key catalyst for the deal. Trump's use of tariffs as a punitive tool-including a 50% levy on Indian goods and threats against EU nations-has pushed traditional allies to seek alternatives. The EU-India pact follows Brussels' recent agreement with the South American Mercosur bloc, also expedited by Trump-era trade friction.
Michael Kugelman, senior fellow for South Asia at the Atlantic Council, noted, "The Trump factor provided a very strong impetus. Both India and the EU face shock tariffs they never expected, prompting them to set aside long-standing disputes."
Leaders frame deal as strategic counterbalance
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen hailed the agreement as "the mother of all deals," emphasizing its role in reducing strategic dependencies amid "an increasingly insecure world." Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi called it a "new blueprint for shared prosperity," linking it to global supply chain resilience during "great turmoil."
"By combining these strengths, we reduce strategic dependencies at a time when trade is increasingly weaponized."
Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission
US criticism and lingering challenges
U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent criticized the deal, claiming it "finances the war against [the EU]" by enabling India's continued purchase of Russian oil. India has rejected such claims, citing energy security needs and longstanding defense ties with Moscow. The agreement also aims to diversify India's defense imports, particularly from France and other EU nations.
However, hurdles remain. Legal teams must finalize the text, followed by ratification in EU member states and the European Parliament-a process experts warn could face delays, as seen with the Mercosur deal. Key unresolved issues include intellectual property, agriculture, and carbon emissions.
Carbon tax imbalance raises concerns
The EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), which taxes imports based on carbon emissions, poses a risk. The Global Trade Research Initiative, a Delhi-based think tank, warned that Indian exports could face carbon taxes in Europe while EU goods enter India duty-free, creating an uneven playing field.
Business groups cautiously optimistic
Industries in both regions welcomed the deal for expanding market access. Fredrik Persson, president of BusinessEurope, called it an "important first step," stressing that "implementation will be key." The pact also aligns with India's broader push for free trade agreements, including ongoing talks with the UK and other partners.
Future of US-India-EU relations
While the deal strengthens EU-India ties, neither side intends to sever relations with the U.S., a critical market for both. Analysts suggest the agreement could provide leverage in future negotiations with Washington, though Trump's response remains unpredictable.
Kugelman added, "India sees this partnership as a way to counter China's trade dominance, while the EU views India as a strategic partner in its own efforts to reduce reliance on Beijing."
