Ask Onix
Culture vs. genetics: How environment shapes identity
A childhood conversation in rural India forced one writer to question whether she would be the same person if raised elsewhere. Science now offers answers to this age-old debate.
The spark of a question
On a sweltering afternoon near Kolkata, a 10-year-old girl sat with her cousin, sharing puffed rice drizzled with mustard oil. The cousin's question cut through the quiet: "Do people in Sweden really eat cows and pigs?" When the girl-raised in Sweden by an Indian mother-nodded, her cousin pressed further: "Then do they eat dogs and cats too?"
The exchange revealed a stark cultural divide. While the Swedish girl saw livestock as food, her cousin, a devoted animal lover, recoiled at the idea. The moment crystallized a question that would linger: If I had grown up in India, would I think, feel, or even dream differently?
Nature's half of the equation
Genetics provide a foundation, but not the full blueprint. Ziada Ayorech, a psychiatric geneticist at the University of Oslo, explains that DNA alone doesn't define us. Born in Uganda, raised in Canada, and later living in the UK and Norway, Ayorech reflects: "Every place I've lived has left its mark. It's impossible to imagine I'd be the same person otherwise."
A landmark 2015 analysis of 14 million twins across 50 years of research found that genetics account for roughly 50% of trait variations-from political beliefs to psychiatric conditions. The rest? Environment.
Some traits lean heavier on biology. IQ, for example, is over 50% heritable in adulthood, while personality hovers around 40%. Yet even extroversion, a trait Ayorech embodies, adapts to setting. In Norway, where spontaneous street conversations are rare, she's quieter than in the UK-but her genes still pull her toward social interactions.
Culture's invisible hand
Ching-Yu Huang, a cross-cultural psychologist at National Taiwan University, argues that culture rewires the brain. "You'd be a different person if raised in Taiwan," she says. "Your neural pathways would form differently, even with identical DNA."
Research underscores this. Western cultures often emphasize individualism-defining oneself by personal traits like humor or intelligence. In contrast, collectivist societies, such as Japan, prioritize social roles (e.g., "father" or "student"). Brain scans reveal this divide: Westerners' self-awareness centers activate when thinking about themselves, while Chinese participants' light up when considering their mothers.
A 2022 study across 22 countries found that cultures valuing self-discipline (e.g., India, Germany) scored higher in dutifulness, while egalitarian societies (e.g., Canada, New Zealand) leaned toward openness and agreeableness. Even perception shifts: Westerners focus on objects in a scene, while East Asians notice context, like water color in an underwater image.
The limits of binary thinking
Vivian Vignoles, a psychologist at the University of Sussex, warns against oversimplifying. The "individualist vs. collectivist" divide, he notes, may reflect economic development more than culture. Self-reported data-common in such studies-can also skew results.
Philosophy complicates the picture further. Some argue identity is tied to biology (a specific sperm and egg) or even a soul, unchanging across cultures. Others, like social constructivists, believe surroundings shape core identity. Politics even plays a role: In one study, liberals saw a gay Christian man as true to himself, while conservatives viewed him as betraying his "real" identity.
Philip Goff, a philosopher at Durham University, proposes a middle ground: consciousness is "baked into" our biological hardware, but matures over time. "There's no clear answer," he admits. "Would you be 'you' in another culture? Maybe not entirely."
A question without answers
For those raised between cultures, the debate feels personal. The writer who pondered her Kolkata roots still wonders: Would I have been more dutiful? Less extroverted? Would my sense of humor even exist? Science suggests the answer is yes-at least in part. Yet the mystery of identity endures, as fluid as the cultures that shape it.
