Ask Onix
Debunking the weight gain myth
For decades, women have reported weight gain as a side effect of the contraceptive pill, making it the most commonly cited concern. However, extensive research has found no conclusive evidence linking the pill to long-term weight increases. A comprehensive review of 49 studies on combined oral contraceptives-those containing synthetic oestrogen and progesterone-concluded that "no large effect is evident," though researchers noted a lack of high-quality studies to draw definitive conclusions.
The psychology behind the belief
Endocrinologist Maria Gallo of Ohio State University suggests that the perceived link between the pill and weight gain may stem from a cognitive bias known as apophenia-the tendency to perceive patterns where none exist. This phenomenon is particularly strong when individuals expect a specific outcome, such as weight changes after starting a new medication.
"It's similar to the misconception that vaccines cause health problems," Gallo explained. "When you administer a treatment to a large population, some will inevitably experience health issues, whether or not they're related to the intervention."
Gallo also pointed out that natural weight fluctuations-such as the average annual gain of half a kilogram (just over a pound) starting in early adulthood-often coincide with the period when many women begin using contraception. This timing may lead some to mistakenly attribute weight changes to the pill.
How the pill reshapes the body
While the pill does not cause significant weight gain, studies reveal it can alter body composition and fat distribution. Researchers have identified three key mechanisms: muscle development, fat storage, and fluid retention.
Muscle mass reduction
In 2009, exercise physiologist Steven Riechman of Texas A&M University discovered an unexpected effect of the pill during a study on muscle growth. Women taking oral contraceptives gained 40% less muscle mass after 10 weeks of resistance training compared to those not on the pill.
The discrepancy appears linked to synthetic progesterone, which may interfere with muscle-building signals by binding to the same proteins as the hormone DHEA-a naturally occurring steroid that promotes muscle growth. "We're confident the progesterone is responsible," Riechman said, though he emphasized the need for further research.
Fat redistribution
The pill may also influence where fat is stored in the body. Oestrogen and progesterone play a crucial role in developing typically female fat distribution patterns, such as wider hips and larger breasts. Some studies suggest that higher-oestrogen pills can increase subcutaneous fat-particularly around the thighs, hips, and breasts-though not necessarily overall body fat.
Bloating and fluid retention
Synthetic oestrogen in the pill can cause fluid retention by affecting kidney function, leading to bloating and temporary swelling in fat cells. This effect is more pronounced in areas where women naturally store more fat, such as the breasts, hips, and thighs. While this swelling is temporary, it may explain why some women report changes in clothing fit or cup size.
A 1990s Swedish study found that women on the pill had larger breasts than those who had never taken it, with size fluctuations throughout the menstrual cycle. The researchers suggested this could be due to fluid retention or prolonged breast tissue growth, though the exact mechanism remains unclear.
Balancing risks and benefits
Despite these subtle physical changes, millions of women consider the pill a worthwhile trade-off. As one Reddit user noted, "No birth control at all is likely to lead to 11 to 15 kilograms (25 to 35 pounds) of weight gain over nine months."
The pill's effects on body shape are complex and vary among individuals. While it does not cause long-term weight gain, its influence on muscle mass, fat distribution, and fluid retention can lead to noticeable changes in how clothes fit and how the body looks.
Join the conversation
This article is part of The Health Gap, a series exploring how men and women experience healthcare differently. Share your experiences or discuss women's health by joining the Future Woman Facebook group.
