Ask Onix
AI disrupts creative industries as artists weigh its impact
From galleries to writing studios, creators are grappling with the implications of artificial intelligence tools that can mimic human artistry, sparking debates over authenticity, copyright, and the future of creative work.
Robot artist sparks debate on what defines art
Ai-Da, a humanoid robot marketed as the world's first ultra-realistic robotic artist, has thrust the conversation into the spotlight. In 2024, her portrait of Alan Turing fetched over $1 million (£836,667) at a Sotheby's auction, reigniting questions about the nature of art and the role of machines in its creation. Yet, the most pressing discussions are unfolding far from high-end auction houses, in local studios and online forums.
Local backlash leads to community-driven dialogue
In Hull, curator and artist Lucy Brooke found herself at the center of a controversy after a nearby gallery advertised a paid workshop where participants were instructed to use ChatGPT to generate images. The announcement triggered a public outcry among local artists, prompting Brooke to organize a free online session to explore AI's broader implications.
The event focused on the environmental, political, and social impacts of AI, followed by an open discussion. Brooke noted that the conversation quickly shifted toward collaboration, challenging the stereotype of artists as solitary figures. "The overwhelming view from creatives was about community," she said, emphasizing that artists today frequently share their processes and ideas.
However, the discussion also surfaced deeper concerns about "copyright, plagiarism, and exploitation." Brooke hopes artists can unite to advocate for clearer policies around AI usage and regulation, arguing, "There's no point in an art gallery if there aren't artists."
Illustrator adapts to AI's growing influence
Eleanor Tomlinson, an illustrator from Broomfleet in East Yorkshire, has built a career around her watercolor works celebrating the countryside and wildlife. Her sketch of Queen Elizabeth II walking hand-in-hand with Paddington Bear during the 2022 Platinum Jubilee brought her widespread recognition. However, her distinctive style has also made her a target for AI replication.
"I've seen things go around that have my signature on it," she said, referring to images that were modified and circulated online without her consent. Initially upset, she has since adopted a more pragmatic approach, focusing on educating others about how to identify authentic work. "There is no point getting really upset and angry about it," she said.
Tomlinson acknowledges the rapid advancements in AI-generated imagery, describing the pace as "scary." She admits it is becoming increasingly difficult to distinguish between human-made and AI-created art. Yet, she remains optimistic, drawing parallels to the introduction of photography, which did not eliminate portrait artists. For her, the key differentiator is the personal connection she offers clients-a quality she believes AI cannot replicate.
Writer grapples with ethical dilemmas and job security
Author Alan Raw, whose books draw heavily on personal experiences, expresses mixed feelings about AI's role in literature. He is particularly troubled by the unauthorized use of published works to train AI models. "I don't like the fact that I have a book which has been published and without permission some AI models are being trained on books," he said. "That kind of hurts a little bit because I wrote it; it feels personal to me."
However, Raw also sees potential benefits. As a writer of climate fiction and non-fiction, he wonders if AI could help disseminate his ideas more widely. "If AI is going to train a model on that and then distribute it, maybe that's a good thing?" he mused.
When it comes to commissioned writing, Raw is less optimistic. "AI is getting really good at doing that," he admitted. "I think I will get replaced." As a creative writing tutor, he has also noticed AI's influence on students' work, with some submissions clearly incorporating AI-generated text. He worries this trend could erode essential narrative skills and the joy of self-expression.
Human creativity remains at the heart of the debate
Despite differing perspectives, artists and writers share a common belief: creativity is inherently human, rooted in lived experience, community, and skill. As AI continues to transform the creative landscape, the value of human connection may emerge as the defining factor in what endures.
